Regular Board Meeting - Closed Session 4:00 PM Morgan Hill USD June 16, 2020 6:00PM Zoom Meeting (For Public Comment, please contact Kelly Schriefer at schrieferk@mhusd.org)
Topic: Board of Education Regular Meeting
Time: Jun 16, 2020
4:00 PM Closed Session
6:00 PM Open Session
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84486304980
Meeting ID: 844 8630 4980
One tap mobile
+16699009128,,84486304980# US (San Jose)
+12532158782,,84486304980# US (Tacoma)
Dial by your location
+1 669 900 9128 US (San Jose)
+1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma)
+
|
Members of the public may address the Board at this time regarding items on the Closed Session agenda. The Board of Education reserves the right to limit speaking time to three (3) minutes or less per individual. |
|
|
|
Submitted by: Jessie Swift, Coordinator Student Services Glen Webb, Director of Curriculum, Instruction and Assessment Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services
|
|
|
|
Submitted by: Jessie Swift, Coordinator Student Services Glen Webb, Director Curriculum, Instruction and Assessment Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services |
|
|
Submitted by: Jessie Swift, Coordinator Student Services Glen Webb, Director Curriculum, Instruction and Assessment Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services |
|
|
Items listed under CONSENT are considered to be routine by the Board of Education and will be enacted by one motion at this time. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a board member or citizen so requests.
|
|
|
|
This is opportunity for communication regarding items not on the agenda. Members of the public may address the Board regarding items on the agenda immediately prior to their being discussed by the Board.
|
|
|
|
The District contracts with consultants or independent contractors who can provide valuable and necessary specialized services not normally required on a continuing basis. Pursuant to Education Code 17604 and Board Policy 3312(a), the Superintendent or designee (employees identified in Bd.Ed. 2017-18 Reso 058) has the authority to enter into contracts with a value up to $100,000 on behalf of the District. These contracts must be subsequently ratified by the Board.
The attached document lists the contracts executed by the Superintendent or designee for the months of April and May 2020. |
|
Submitted by:
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
200616 April 2020 Contracts 200616 May 2020 Contracts
|
|
|
Cash donations and other types of donations have been listed on the attached resolution. The following is a donation action resolution to accept donations and increase budgets as a result of cash donations and make changes between funds as needed. |
|
Cash donations were included in the 2019-20 budget of each site
|
Submitted by:
Victoria Knutson, Director Fiscal Services
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
200616 Donations Reso
|
|
|
On June 19, 2018, Frank Serrano was approved as a member of the Measure G Citizens' Oversight Committee representing the position of “Parent /Guardian of a child enrolled in our District.” Mr. Serrano has been a valuable member of the COC who attends regularly and Staff is requesting Board approval for the extension of appointment for Frank Serrano to an additional term, expiring June of 2022. |
|
Submitted by:
Casino Fajardo, Director Construction and Modernization
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
|
|
The City of Morgan Hill and PG&E are requesting Right of Way (ROW) easements on the District's property at the corner of Hale Avenue and Main Avenue APN 764-16-028 (formally VTA site). These improvements are in conjunction with the Santa Clara Valley Water District’s plan to underground the Upper Llagas Creek Flood Protection Project.
The area shown within the Resolution as Exhibit A shows the area where PG&E would need an easement to underground the current overhead lines to enhance the intersection at Main Avenue and Hale Avenue. Since this would only be an underground easement it will not reduce the size of the parcel.
The City of Morgan Hill is also requesting a ROW easement at the same location in order to add a right turn only lane at the intersection of Main Avenue and Hale Avenue. This however will require a purchase agreement with the City as it will reduce the parcel size (site alterations are show in Exhibit A of the Resolution). The City and the District are working on legal descriptions of the site and the requested property along with purchase price. Approval of the purchase of the property for the easement will be presented to the Board at a future date for consideration.
Education Code Section 17556 allows for the dedication of the easement by the District with a two-step process. Education Code Section 17557 provides that the District may dedicate the easement only if the Board first adopts a resolution declaring its intention to dedicate the easement in a regular open meeting by a two-thirds vote. After adopting Resolutions of intention to dedicate the easement and prior to the final approval of the Resolutions, Education Code Section 17558 requires the District to give ten days notice of a public hearing and consideration of adopting a Resolution to dedicate the easement.
After considering the staff’s presentation, public comments, and any protests, at the public hearing, the Board will consider adopting a Resolution to Dedicate an easement for access and utility purposes at a future Board meeting date. |
|
TBD. The purchase amount from the City of Morgan Hill will be deposited into the Mello Roos Fund as the property was initially acquired with proceeds from the Mello Roos Fund. |
Submitted by:
Anessa Espinosa, Director Facilities
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
200616 MHUSD Resolution of Intent to Grant Easement Conduit 200616 Reso Intent to Grant Easement
|
|
|
The purpose of our supplemental reading list is to provide teachers with a guide of approved fiction for instruction by grade level. Maintaining a list also provides stakeholders an opportunity to offer input and critique of the list to ensure that potential disagreements over appropriate fictional reading are heard in advance of the books being used. The books on the list come from a number of sources endorsing their use as supplemental reading; however, as opinions and values vary among stakeholders, this review process ensures that all have an opportunity to be heard and to subsequently protect teachers using the approved readings.
Recommended additions to the list that have been reviewed by curriculum council and will come back to the Governing Board for action at the next regularly scheduled Board meeting to allow the public time to comment include:
Title | Author | Grade Level | on CDE List? | Common Sense Media? | The boy in the striped pajamas | John Boyne | | yes, 6-12 | | The Witch Boy | Molly Ostertag | 3-7 | no | ages 8+ | George | Alex Gino | | yes, 6-8 | | Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda | Becky Albertalli | 2-5, 9-12 | yes, 9-12 | | Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe | Benjamin Alaire Saenz | 6-8, 9-12 (scholastic) | yes, 9-12 | | Just Mercy | Bryan Stevenson | 11 | no | 13+ | Internment | Samira Ahmed | 10 | no | 13+ | |
|
Submitted by:
Glen Webb, Director Curriculum, Instruction and Assessment
Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services |
|
|
Executive Order (EO) N-56-20 was established on April 22, 2020, to address the impact of continued school closures in response to the COVID-19 pandemic and the local educational agencies’ (LEA) ability to conduct meaningful annual planning, and the ability to meaningfully engage stakeholders in these processes. The Executive Order issued a timeline and approval waivers for the Local Control and Accountability Plan and Budget Overview for Parents as well as waving certain budgetary requirements.
As required by EO N-56-20, a written report explaining the changes to program offerings that MHUSD has made in response to school closures to address the COVID-19 emergency, the major impacts of such closures on students and families, and a description of how MHUSD is meeting the needs of its unduplicated student was prepared. This report was reviewed by the Board on June 2 and is being brought forward for adoption at tonight’s Board meeting. |
|
Submitted by: Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services |
200616 COVID Action Report Adoption
|
|
|
See attached
|
|
Included in adopted budget
|
Submitted by:
Fawn Myers, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
Steve Betando, Superintendent |
200616 Personnel Order
|
|
|
The Special Education Department will provide to the Board this evening an overview of their revised vision and mission and the current state of Special Education enrollment and programs. |
|
Submitted by: Dr. Rebecca O'Brien, Director Special Education Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services |
200616 SPED Vision (1)
|
|
|
Principals are presenting their School Plans for Student Achievement for the 2020-21 School year and will provide the Governing Board with a highlight of their plan. The plans have been drafted, reviewed and approved in collaboration with each school site council and will return as an action item on August 4 for approval.
|
|
$1,038,000 from LCFF Supplemental, $562,747 from Title I, and $1,148,299 from unrestricted lottery funds for a total of $2,749,046
|
Submitted by: Mary Alice Callahan, Principal Barrett Elementary Darren McDonald, Principal El Toro Health Science Academy Patrick Buchser, Principal JAMM Debbie Stewart, Principal Los Paseos Elementary Debbie Grove, Principal Nordstrom Elementary Julie Page, Principal Paradise Valley Engineering Academy Alex Aasen, Principal San Martin Gwinn DI School and Environmental Science Academy Shannon Rafat, Principal Walsh STEAM Academy Nanette Donohue, Principal Britton Middle School Aubrie Dimas, Interim Principal Martin Murphy Middle School Lisa Martin, Principal Central High School Tanya Calabretta, Principal Live Oak High School Courtney Macko, Principal Sobrato High School Glen Webb, Director Curriculum, Instruction and Assessent Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services |
200616 Barrett SPSA 200616 Britton SPSA 200616 Central SPSA 200616 El Toro SPSA 200616 JAMM SPSA 200616 Live Oak SPSA 200616 Los Paseos SPSA 200616 Murphy SPSA 200616 Nordstrom SPSA 200616 Paradise Valley SPSA 200616 SMG SPSA 200616 Sobrato SPSA 200616 Walsh SPSA
|
|
|
On June 4th, the Board participated in a Budget Workshop where Staff provided an overview of the District's finances, reviewed current multi-year projections trends, the potential consequences of a negative or qualified budget, and the Budget Committee's recommendations for reductions. The Board discussed reserve levels and multi-year strategies to address the District's structural deficit in light of the Governor's proposed 10% reduction in education funding. Tonight's agenda item builds on the Budget Workshop by presenting the Board with several options for further discussion:
-
Option A: Budget reduction of $4M in 2021-22 and $4M in 2022-23
-
Option B: Budget reduction of $2M in 2020-21, $2.1M in 2021-22, and $2.1M in 2022-23
-
Option C: Budget reduction of $5M in 2021-22 and $5M in 2022-23
-
Option D: Budget reduction of $2.5M in 2020-21, $2.5M in 2021-22, and $2.5M in 2022-23
Background
Assembly Bill 1200 (AB 1200) enacted in 1992 was established to help ensure that local educational agencies throughout California were adequately prepared to meet and sustain their financial obligations. The first level of fiscal oversight remains with local boards of education and their administration; however AB 1200 expanded the role of the County Office of Education in monitoring school districts to ensure that these districts could meet their multi-year financial commitments.
AB 1200 requires that multi-year financial projections be included as part of the budget and interim reporting periods. Districts must certify their financial status at each reporting period as one of the following:
- Positive: LEA will meet its financial obligations for the current fiscal year and subsequent two fiscal years
- Qualified: LEA may not meet its financial obligations for the current fiscal year or two subsequent years
- Negative: LEA will not meets its financial obligations for the remainder of the current fiscal year or for the subsequent fiscal year
Multi-year financial projections are a tool used by the district to ensure that it will be able to meet its financial obligations in the current and two subsequent fiscal years. If the district is not able to meet its financial obligations for the current or two subsequent fiscal years, the county superintendent of schools must notify the district’s governing board and the Superintendent of Public Instruction of the determination. The county office must also adhere to Education Code section 42127.6 in assisting the district. This assistance can include assigning a fiscal expert to advise the district on financial problems, conducting a study of the financial and budgetary conditions of the district, and submitting a proposal for addressing the district’s fiscal condition.
In evaluating the multi-year projection, much attention is focused on the “bottom line” which demonstrates the district’s undesignated, unappropriated fund balance. If the bottom line demonstrates a positive unappropriated fund balance, this amount may be used by the Governing Board and/ or Superintendent to improve educational programs, increase employee compensation or spend in other categories. However, if the unappropriated fund balance is negative, the budget must be adjusted by the amount of the deficit spending to sustain the recommended minimum reserve levels under AB 1200 guidelines (currently 3%). The projection must be viewed comprehensively and the district must determine what compounding effects using any or all of the unappropriated fund balance will have on the projection in the current and future years.
There are inherent limitations with any projection of financial data because projections are based on certain criteria and assumptions rather than on exact calculations. These limitations include issues such as accuracy of baseline data, unpredictable timing of negotiations, enrollment trends, and changing economic conditions at the state, federal and local levels. Therefore, the multi-year projection should be evaluated as a trend based on certain criteria and assumptions rather than a prediction of exact numbers. The multi-year projection is updated throughout the year, including at least at each interim financial reporting period and before settling negotiations to maintain the most accurate and meaningful data. |
|
Submitted by:
Victoria Knutson, Director Fiscal Services
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
200616 MYP Presentation
|
|
|
The proposed budgets for 2020-21 for all District funds are enclosed for Board approval. The restricted non-general funds were presented to the Board on May 19, 2020 and the general fund budget was presented to the Board on June 2, 2020. In addition, the Board held a public hearing on June 2, 2020 as required by Education Code section 42103 to solicit public comment on the 2020-21 proposed budget.
Attached are the following documents which were provided at the prior Board meetings:
- Summary of income, expenses and fund balance for all funds
- Standard Account Code Structure (SACS) financial reports for all funds reflecting 2019-20 estimated actuals and 2020-21 proposed budget
Since the June 2, 2020 Public Hearing, the following changes were made to the 2020-21 proposed budget:
- Reduction of $1.5M in expenditures in the 2019-20 budget, increasing the projected 2020-21 beginning fund balance
- Employer rates for PERS and STRS updated to reflect the Governor's May Revision which resulted in a savings of $1M
- Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief (ESSER) dollars of $644,000 included in the budget supplanting operating expenses in the Unrestricted General Fund
- Deferred Maintenance contribution of $300,000 eliminated (ongoing reduction)
- Assigned Fund Balance designation updated to reflect recapturing monies from Supplemental Funds,One-Time Discretionary, and IMF monies
Education Code Section 42127 states that, “no later than 45 days after the Governor signs the annual Budget Act, the school district shall make available for public review any revisions in revenues and expenditures that it has made to its budget to reflect the funding made available by that Budget Act.” Note that this does not specify that revisions must be made; rather, it requires that any revisions that the District chooses to make be available for public review within 45 days after the Governor signs the budget. If the District decides to make a budget revision as a result of the Budget Act, those revisions would be presented to the Board in August 2020. |
|
Approve annual budget for 2020-21 school year in accordance with Education code 42122-42127 |
Submitted by:
Victoria Knutson, Director Fiscal Services
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
2020-21 Adopted Budget - All SACS forms 2020-21 Adopted Budget - Detailed Fund Summary 2020-21 Adopted Budget - Form CB 2020-21 Adopted Budget - Form CC 2020-21 Statement of Reasons for Excess Reserves
|
|
|
Public Hearing:
In accordance with SB 858 and Education Code 42127, school districts are required to include the following information for review and discussion with their adopted and revised budgets:
- The minimum recommended reserve for economic uncertainties for each fiscal year identified in the budget
- The combined assigned and unassigned ending fund balances that are in excess of the minimum recommended reserve for economic uncertainties for each fiscal year identified in the budget, pursuant to Education Code Section 33128(a). The fund balances included are Fund 01, General Fund, and Fund 17, Special Reserve Fund for Other Than Capital Outlay Projects.
- A statement of reasons that substantiates the need for an assigned and unassigned ending fund balance in excess of the minimum recommended reserve for economic uncertainties for each fiscal year
Beginning in 2015-16, school districts must include this information each time it files an adopted or revised budget with the County Superintendent of Schools. The County Superintendent of Schools shall determine whether a school district’s adopted or revised budget complied with these requirements.
SB 858 also includes provisions for reserve caps or limits if four State revenue conditions are met. For 2020-21, it is anticipated that not all of the conditions will be met and the reserve limits will not be activated. As amended by Senate Bill (SB) 751 in September 2017, the reserve limit only applies in a fiscal year immediately following a fiscal year in which the State makes a deposit of at least three percent (3%) of the Proposition 98 funding into the State’s Public School System Stabilization Account (the reserve that was created by Proposition 2). If the reserve cap was activated, a district with an ADA of 400,000 or less would be limited to a combined assigned or unassigned ending balance of ten percent (10%) in the General Fund and Special Reserve Fund for Other Than Capital Outlay. The County Superintendent of Schools may grant an exemption of this requirement for up to two consecutive fiscal years within a three year period to any district that documents extraordinary fiscal circumstances that substantiate the need for a reserve in excess of the limit.
In March 2020, the California Department of Education released the 2018-19 Unaudited Actual reports which allow for the calculation of the average reserve levels by district type – for unified school districts the average General Fund plus Special Reserve for Other Than Capital Outlay Projects is 17.26%. This is remarkably close to the 16.67% minimum (2 months of payroll) recommended reserves for local governments by the Governmental Finance Officers Association and the District's Board policy.
Education Code Section 42127(a)(2)(B) requires a statement of the reasons that substantiates the need for assigned and unassigned ending fund balances in excess of the minimum reserve standard for economic uncertainties for each of the three fiscal years identified in the budget submission. The attached worksheets are based on the current multi-year projections which do not include any expenditure reductions. Worksheets for budget years 2020-21 and 2021-22 are included since these fiscal year have an assigned and unassigned ending fund balances in excess of the minimum reserve standard; however, a worksheet is not provided for 2022-23 since the District does not have excess reserves for this fiscal year. |
|
The district will have excess reserves to report in years 2020-21 and 2021-22 |
Submitted by:
Victoria Knutson, Director Fiscal Services
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
200616 2020-21 Statement of Reasons for Excess Reserves
|
|
|
On September 15, 2017, the Board of Education approved the Series B preliminary project list. The $80 million in proceeds from Series B were broken into five main categories: Britton Middle School reconstruction, Nordstrom Elementary portable replacement, Jackson Academy of Math and Music new multi-use room/gym, technology infrastructure and instructional technology replacement, and construction management. Of the $80 million series bond funds, $40.9 million has been spent for a total of 50% of Series B as of April 30, 2020. |
|
Submitted by:
Casino Fajardo, Director Construction and Modernization
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer |
200616 Measure G Update
|
|
|
Oversight of cash is always an important responsibility for the Fiscal Services Department, but it is especially important during difficult and uncertain economic times. Ensuring the availability of adequate cash reserves is a vital function since an emergency appropriation (e.g. a state loan and takeover of a school districts governance) is triggered by insufficient cash flow not a budget shortfall.
At the May 19, 2020 Board meeting, Staff provided an update to the Board regarding internal and external strategies used to ensure adequate cash levels to meet the District's needs. One of those strategies that is typically used is a Tax and Revenue Anticipation Notes (TRANs) which is a common method for governmental agencies to mitigate a cash shortfall. TRANs are short-term loans that are issued by school districts and secured by anticipated tax revenues to be collected from the same fiscal year. TRANs funds may be used for any purpose including current expenses, capital expenditures, repayment of indebtedness or working capital. At the meeting, the Board gave direction for Staff to continue with a TRANs at a level not to exceed $5 million; however, prior to issuing any debt Staff needed to receive final authorization from the Board.
Projecting cash flow this year is more challenging than normal, with the conflicting budget proposals from the Governor and Legislature. During the last recession, a significant decline in state tax revenues prompted numerous apportionment deferrals that caused cash fluctuations and resulted in extensive inter-year and intra-year cash deferrals. It is expected that cash deferrals will be utilized in the Enacted Budget but at what level remains unknown.
The initial cash flow projection indicates that the District will not need to issue a TRAN for the first half of the 2020-21 fiscal year. A TRAN may need to be issued later in the fiscal year to provide cash flow due to the proposed apportionment deferrals especially under the Legislature's proposal if Federal funds are not received. |
|
Submitted by:
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
Steve Betando, Superintendent |
200614 May Revise Apportionment Deferrals
|
|
|
The Governing Board of the Morgan Hill Unified School District must act upon a resolution to eliminate or reduce classified positions due to lack of funds and/or lack of work in order to meet the California Education Code 45308 statutory requirement to serve a layoff notification to the affected employees not later than 60 days prior to the effective date of lay-off. Morgan Hill Unified School District has identified classified positions that shall be eliminated for the 2020-2021 and positions that may be reduced due to adjustments in the educational program.
Each year, school site and departmental administrators review with Human Resources and Business Services to determine staffing needs for the upcoming school year for both classified and certificated employees. Each school site and department’s staffing list is reviewed and changes may be made based on any of the following:
1) Flexibility– during times of uncertain budgetary constraints, staffing levels are analyzed to provide maximum flexibility to minimally meet the prioritized needs.
2) Funding changes – categorical, general funds, and grants may increase or decrease year-to-year, which may result in the need to reduce hours or eliminate a position.
3) Program changes – a school site or district program may change a focus or manner of delivery of services, which may result in the need to reduce hours or eliminate a position.
4) Staffing formulas – due to budgetary and enrollment fluctuations, staffing formulas are reviewed, which may result in an increase or decrease of hours or elimination of a position.
Prior to determining the layoff of classified employees, a review of all vacant positions is conducted. This review enables Human Resources to begin reassigning staffing to vacant positions prior to layoffs. The District also notifies and meets with the leader of the affected bargaining group. For this resolution, the District has met with the Morgan Hill Classified Employee Association to review the need for the layoffs and to examine the impact to affected employees for each position identified for elimination and reduction. Under state law, Education Code §§ 45114, 45115, 45117, 45298, and 45307-9, school districts must provide not less than 60 days’ notice to classified employees of a layoff, including giving notice of any displacement (bumping) and reemployment rights.
The attached resolution identifies classified positions that will be eliminated for the 2020-21 school year and positions that are subject to a reduction in days. The District has already met with the Morgan Hill Classified Employees Association regarding the mitigation of the impact of these layoffs and will continue to meet to identify solutions to ensure the least or minimal impact on the affected employees of the District.
Decisions continue to be made regarding the District’s budget for 2020-21 and the educational plan and calendar that may need to be adjusted due to the COVID-19 pandemic. As in any budget cycle, additional funding may become available, new positions may be identified and/or positions that were eliminated or reduced may be reinstated. It is also possible that additional layoffs may become necessary as the full budgetary impact is known. |
|
Reductions needed to assist in addressing reduced funding |
Submitted by:
Fawn Myers, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
Steve Betando, Superintendent |
200616 Classified MOU 200616 Classified RIF Reso
|
|
|
Superintendent will lead the Board on a discussion of the options for the CSBA conference |
|
Submitted by:
Steve Betando, Superintendent |
|
|
The next REGULAR meeting of the Board of Education is scheduled for Tuesday, August 4, 2020 with Open Session beginning at 6:00pm. The agenda will be available on the District's website by 5:00pm Friday, July 31, 2020. |
|
|
Special Accommodations: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to access the Board meeting room or to otherwise participate at this meeting, including auxiliary aids or services, please contact Kelly Schriefer at 201-6001. Notification at least 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the District to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to the Board meeting.
Documents provided to a majority of the Governing Board regarding an open session item in the agenda will be made available for public inspection in the District Office located at 15600 Concord Circle, Morgan Hill during normal business hours. |
| |
Published: June 12, 2020, 2:10 PM
|