banner

Regular Board Meeting - Closed Session 4:00 PM
Morgan Hill USD
May 19, 2020 6:00PM
Zoom Meeting (For Public Comment, please contact Kelly Schriefer at schrieferk@mhusd.org) Kelly Schriefer is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting. Topic: Regular Board of Education Meeting Time: May 19, 2020 4:00 PM Closed Session 6:00 PM Open Session Join Zoom Meeting https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84732496771?pwd=Ulh5MWw5OEdBOThSVWRERXowaWFOdz09 Meeting ID: 847 3249 6771 Password: 5qGppk One tap mobile +16699009128,,84732496771#,,1#,212453# US (San Jose) +13462487799,,8473249

A. CALL TO ORDER
A.1. PUBLIC COMMENT ON CLOSED SESSION TOPICS
Rationale:
Members of the public may address the Board at this time regarding items on the Closed Session agenda. The Board of Education reserves the right to limit speaking time to three (3) minutes or less per individual.
 
A.2. ADJOURN TO CLOSED SESSION (4:00 PM)
A.3. PUPIL PERSONNEL - Student discipline Education Code §48918 (c)(K-12)
A.4. LIABILITY CLAIMS - Governmental Code Section 54956.95
A.5. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - ANTICIPATED LITIGATION - Significant exposure to litigation pursuant to paragraph (2) or (3) of subdivision (d) of Section 54956.9: one case
A.6. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - EXISTING LITIGATION - Pursuant to subdivision (a) of Government Code §54956.9
A.6.a. EL 17/18-001 v. Morgan Hill Unified School District Case No. 17CV319128
A.7. CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATOR (Government Code § 54957.6) Morgan Hill Classified Employees Association (MHCEA) and Morgan Hill Federation of Teachers (MHFT), Designated representative: Fawn Myers / Morgan Hill Educational Leaders Association (MHELA), Unrepresented employees, Designated representative: Steve Betando, and Superintendent, Designated representative: Karen Rezendes, Lozano Smith
A.8. CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATORS (Government Code §54956.8)
A.9. PUBLIC EMPLOYEE-DISCIPLINE / DISMISSAL / RELEASE / REASSIGNMENT / COMPLAINT (Government Code § 54957 and 54957.1)
A.10. PUBLIC EMPLOYEE APPOINTMENT (Government Code § 54957)
A.11. PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT / PUBLIC EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE EVALUATION (Government Code § 54957) Title: Superintendent
A.12. RECONVENE TO PUBLIC SESSION
B. CALL TO ORDER / PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE (6:00 PM)
C. INTRODUCTION OF BOARD MEMBERS AND STAFF (6:03 PM)
D. RECOGNITIONS / PRESENTATIONS (6:05 PM)
D.1. Flexible Learning Implementation. Teachers' Professional and Personal Perspectives
Rationale:
The following teachers will provide their professional and personal perspectives on flexible learning implementation:

Heather Anderson, Third/Fourth Grade Combo Teacher, Nordstrom Elementary School 
Richard Punches, Math Teacher, Britton Middle School 
Veronica Andrade, English Teacher, Central Continuation High School
 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Pilar Vazquez-Vialva, Assistant Superintendent Educational Services
E. ADOPTION OF AGENDA (6:15 PM)
F. APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR (6:17 PM)
Rationale:
Items listed under CONSENT are considered to be routine by the Board of Education and will be enacted by one motion at this time. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a board member or citizen so requests.
 
G. PUBLIC COMMENT / COMMUNICATIONS (6:20 PM)
Rationale:
This is opportunity for communication regarding items not on the agenda. Members of the public may address the Board regarding items on the agenda immediately prior to their being discussed by the Board.
 
H. COMMUNICATIONS (6:30 PM)
H.1. Closed Session Action Report (Government Code § 54957.1)
H.2. Report: Student Board Member
H.3. Reports: Superintendent / Staff
H.4. Reports: Employee Groups: Morgan Hill Classified Employee Association / Morgan Hill Federation of Teachers / Morgan Hill Educational Leaders Association
H.5. Reports: Board Members
I. CONSENT ITEMS
I.1. BUSINESS SERVICES
I.1.a. Adopt resolution for Committed Fund Balance per GASB 54 for Adult Education (Fund 11) and Deferred Maintenance (Fund 14) for Year Ending June 30, 2020
Rationale:
Fund 11, Adult Education, and Fund 14, Deferred Maintenance, were established to allow districts to account separately for state funding restricted for the Adult Education and Deferred Maintenance programs. Prior to implementation of the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF), these funds met the definition of a special revenue fund. Since LCFF removed program restrictions and LCFF funding is now available for any educational purposes, Fund 11 and 14 no longer meet the definition of a special revenue fund.   

Per the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) Statement 54, districts may continue to use Fund 11 and 14, if formal action is taken, to commit the funds for the purposes for which they were originally intended. By passing this resolution, the Board is committing the fund balances in Fund 11 for the purpose of Adult Education and Fund 14 for the purpose of Deferred Maintenance. These funds may be uncommitted at any time by Board action.

 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Victoria Knutson, Director Fiscal Services
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
Attachments:
200519 202021 Committed Fund Balance Reso
I.1.b. Ratification of contracts executed pursuant to Board Policy 3312 for the month of March 2020
Rationale:
The District contracts with consultants or independent contractors who can provide valuable and necessary specialized services not normally required on a continuing basis. Pursuant to Education Code 17604 and Board Policy 3312(a), the Superintendent or designee (employees identified in Bd.Ed. 2017-18 Reso 058) has the authority to enter into contracts with a value up to $100,000 on behalf of the District. These contracts must be subsequently ratified by the Board.

The attached document lists the contracts executed by the Superintendent or designee for the month of March 2020.

 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
Attachments:
200519 Monthly Contracts
I.1.c. Approve agreements for legal services for fiscal year 2020-21
Rationale:
In accordance with Board Bylaw 9124, the District annually approves contracts for legal services. In evaluating legal counsel, staff has considered the firm or attorney's background; experience and reputation in education law; experience advising or representing school districts in California; fee schedule, and experience of attorneys at the firm who will provide legal services.  Based on these criteria, the following firms are recommended:
  • Burke, Williams & Sorensen
  • Liebert Cassidy Whitmore
  • Lozano Smith
  • Orbach Huff Suarez & Henderson

Having a variety of legal firms allows the District flexibility to select the firm with the most expertise and experience for a particular matter. Since these firms represent many clients in the education field the possibility of conflict of interest could arise, the District will have the option to easily select alternative counsel.

 
Financial Impact:
$150,000 is included in the Adopted General Fund budget for legal services
Comments:
Submitted by:
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
Steve Betando, Superintendent
Attachments:
200519 BWS Legal Services Agreement
200519 LCW Legal Services Agreement
200519 LS Legal Services Agreement
200519 OHSH Legal Services Agreement
I.2. EDUCATIONAL SERVICES
I.3. HUMAN RESOURCES
I.3.a. Approve Declaration of Need for fully qualified educators for the Morgan Hill Unified School District
Rationale:
Annually, the Board is asked to certify that a need may exist to hire fully credentialed teachers for the upcoming school year.  Finding fully qualified teachers in the high-need areas of special education, bilingual certification,  mathematics, and science can be challenging since the current demand exceeds the supply of these credentials.  Additionally, personnel changes that may occur during the school year due to a variety of statutory leaves increases the demand for fully qualified teachers when the mid-year supply of fully credentialed teachers may be low. 

Morgan Hill Unified School District places a strong emphasis on recruiting fully credentialed teachers. To accomplish this, Human Resources posts vacancies on online platforms and with nearby universities' teacher preparation programs and career centers, attends recruitment fairs, and advertises in various professional publications. Despite all recruiting efforts for fully credentialed teachers, due to a teacher shortage and lack of availability of certain credentials, there are times when the District will have the need to hire interns or other short-term permitted teachers.  Annually, the District must estimate the number of teachers without full credentials that they may have the need to hire.  Attached is the Declaration of Need which will be submitted to the Santa Clara County Office of Education and to the Commission on Teacher Credentialing. These numbers are estimates only for the 2020-21 school year.

The Commission on Teacher Credentialing requires the Board of Education to take action to approve the Declaration of Need in an open session of a regularly scheduled board meeting.  Upon approval, the necessary documents will then be timely filed with the appropriate agencies.

The District will continue to place its emphasis on the recruitment and retention of highly qualified, fully credentialed teachers throughout the school year.

 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Fawn Myers, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
Attachments:
200519 Declaration of Need
I.3.b. Approve personnel action to employ, re-employ, promote, reassign, accept resignation, accept retirement, and authorize related compensation
Rationale:
See attached
 
Financial Impact:
Included in adopted budget
Comments:
Submitted by:
Fawn Myers, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
Attachments:
200519 Personnel Order
I.4. SUPERINTENDENT
I.4.a. Approve the minutes from the Regular Board meeting of May 5, 2020
Comments:
Submitted by:
Steve Betando, Superintendent
Attachments:
200519 Meeting Minutes May 5, 2020
I.4.b. Adopt resolution authorizing compensation for Carol Gitten's absence from a regular meeting of the Morgan Hill Unified School District Board of Education held on May 5, 2020
Rationale:
The attached resolution authorizing compensation for Carol Ann Gitten's absence from a regular meeting of the Board of Education held on May 5, 2020 is submitted for approval in accordance with Board Policy 9250.
 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Steve Betando, Superintendent
Attachments:
200519 BOE Absence Reso Gittens
J. GENERAL BUSINESS - PUBLIC SESSION ITEMS FOR BOARD DISCUSSION
J.1. Governor's May Revise for 2020-21 and Budget Committee Update (6:40 PM)
Rationale:
Information / Discussion:

The Governor's January budget proposal has historically been reliable in providing direction to the District in establishing a framework of assumptions to use in developing next year's budget; however, the State must now recast and significantly adjust its revenue projections downward from the Governor's January's Budget in light of the COVID-19 health pandemic that has shut down the state, national, and global economies. 

Staff will present information on the Governor's May Revision, and its effect on the District's budget including funding proposals for the Local Control Funding Formula. Staff will also present an update on the work of the District's Budget Committee and timelines for potential budget reductions.

 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
J.2. Proposed 2020-21 adopted budget for the restricted non-general funds as reported in the Standardized Account Code Structure (SACS) report (7:00 PM)
Rationale:
The proposed adopted budget for the restricted non-general funds is being presented for review and discussion.  Information included in these funds is based on the Governor’s January budget proposal. 

Attached is a summary description of each of the restricted non-general funds and a spreadsheet summarizing the budgeted amounts.

The proposed adopted budget report for all funds will be presented at the June 2, 2020 Board meeting as part of the public hearing prior to the Board’s adoption of the District’s 2020-21 budget on June 16, 2020.

 
Financial Impact:
Proposed budgets for the restricted non-general fund as reported in the SACS report
Comments:
Submitted by:
Victoria Knutson, Director Fiscal Services
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
Attachments:
200519 2020-21 Adopted Budget Other Funds Narrative
200519 2020-21 Adopted Budget Other Funds SACS forms
200519 2020-21 Adopted Budget Other Funds Summary
J.3. Cash Management Strategies: Adopt resolution allowing participation in California School Cash Reserve Program in order to issue Tax and Revenue Anticipation Notes (TRANs) and adopt resolution to establish temporary inter-fund transfer of special or restricted fund moneys (7:20 PM)
Rationale:
Oversight of cash is always an important responsibility for the Fiscal Services Department, but it is especially important during difficult and uncertain economic times. Ensuring the availability of adequate cash reserves is a vital function since an emergency appropriation (e.g. a state loan and takeover of a school districts governance) is triggered by insufficient cash flow not a budget shortfall.

During the last recession, a significant decline in state tax revenues prompted numerous apportionment deferrals that caused cash fluctuations and resulted in extensive inter-year and intra-year cash deferrals. It is expected that cash deferrals will be one of the first tools the state uses to stabilize its own cash flow and to control in what year Proposition 98 appropriations are attributed. Cash deferrals are more favorable than actual funding reductions but typically require districts to borrow internally or externally to ensure sufficient cash is available for operating expenses.

Given that neither the May Revision or the June enacted budget will provide definitive answers about budget and apportionment schedules, it is critical that school districts analyze and proactively plan for various scenarios that may adversely impact cash flow in order to avoid cash shortfalls.

Below is a narrative describing various strategies Morgan Hill Unified School District utilizes to manage cash flow. It is important to emphasize the District has a very strong cash position (e.g. end of month cash position for the current fiscal year ranged from $15.8M - $33.3M); however, the District is proactively monitoring and has begun utilizing various strategies to build cash balances in advance of expected deferrals.

Internal Cash Management Strategies

The District has very little control over cash inflows given that the timing of inflows are established in federal, state, and county statue. The District has more control over cash outflows, although the majority of monthly expenses are attributed to payroll and benefits. In order to preserve cash for critical operational functions, the District may delay any nonessential expenditures, postpone discretionary purchases, or stretch payment terms (e.g. 30 > 45 days).

The District also has the ability to use cash resources available outside of the District’s General Fund – referred to as interfund borrowing. Education Code Section 42603 allows temporary borrowing between funds to satisfy temporary shortfalls in operating cash and is commonly used among school districts. The District must ensure compliance with the legal requirements including the maximum borrowing limits and repayment requirements as specified in code. The Education Code does not limit interfund borrowing authority to particular funds and includes no specific exclusions for funds although borrowing from bond funds is not advisable for a variety of reasons. The District has not needed to utilize interfund borrowing since 2010-11.

District staff recommends approval of the Resolution to Establish Temporary Interfund Transfer of Special or Restricted Fund Moneys in order to allow staff to borrow funds as permitted under Education Code Section 42603 in order to manage cash shortfalls. This is a preferred strategy to manage cash shortfalls because it is inexpensive and relatively easy to implement as it requires only coordination with the County Treasurer.

External Cash Management Strategies

Tax and Revenue Anticipation Notes (TRANs) are a common method for governmental agencies to mitigate a cash shortfall. TRANs are short-term loans that are issued by school districts and secured by anticipated tax revenues to be collected from the same fiscal year. TRANs funds may be used for any purpose including current expenses, capital expenditures, repayment of indebtedness or working capital. Many districts access TRANs through ‘pools’ such as the California School Cash Reserve Program. By ‘pooling’ financing requests, districts are able to minimizing borrowing costs. There is usually a 60-day lead time to complete a TRANs transaction as well the shared cost of issuance fees (i.e. attorney, financial advisor, underwriter, and other professional services).

The District participated in California School Cash Reserve Program program consistency from 1997-98 to 2013-14. Staff recommends approval of this resolution to allows the District the option (not the requirement) to participate in California School Cash Reserve Program TRANs. The final determination whether to issue TRANs would be made by staff based on the information in the enacted budget and projected cash flow.

 
Financial Impact:
TBD based on size and interest rate of TRANs
Comments:
Submitted by:
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
Steve Betando, Superintendent
Attachments:
200519 Inter Fund Borrowing Reso
200519 TRANS Reso
J.4. Layoff timeline for probationary and permanent certificated and permanent classified employees for 2020-21 school year (7:40 PM)
Rationale:

Layoff Timeline 

for Probationary and Permanent Certificated Employees

and Permanent Classified Employees

for 2020-21 School Year


There is a provision in the Education Code that allows a second window for certificated layoffs should the increase in the enacted budget be less than two percent.  This provision may need to be used across the state as districts absorb the impact to school funding as a result of reduced taxes collected due to COVID-19.


Ed Code 44955.5 (a):  During the time period between five days after the enactment of the Budget Act and August 15 of the fiscal year to which that Budget Act applies, if the governing board of a school district determines that its total revenue limit per unit of average daily attendance for the fiscal year of that Budget Act has not increased by at least 2 percent, and if in the opinion of the governing board it is therefore necessary to decrease the number of permanent employees in the district, the governing board may terminate the services of any permanent or probationary certificated employees of the district, including employees holding a position that requires an administrative or supervisory credential. The termination shall be pursuant to Sections 44951 and 44955 but, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in Sections 44951 and 44955, in accordance with a schedule of notice and hearing adopted by the governing board.


In order to complete any final notices for summer layoffs by August 15, the Morgan Hill Unified School District will use the following timeline:



May 1-31

Review employee classification, seniority lists (approved earlier this year), tie-breaking criteria, and current staffing levels with labor leaders; share information regarding potential personnel reductions with Budget Committee

May 19 Board Meeting

Summer layoff timeline introduced as information item to the Board

June 2 or June 16 Board Meeting

If needed, resolutions for Classified and Certificated layoffs

June 3-30

Notify affected classified employees (begin 60-day layoff notice). Notified employees remain on a rehire list for 39 months, and employees are called back in order of seniority.

Serve Certificated employees with Notice of Layoff (via email and certified regular mail). The notice is for layoff for the 2020-21 school year

Within 7 calendar days of receipt of notice

Certificated employees may request a hearing (or the union can do it on behalf of everyone given a notice); a hearing is to verify that the seniority list and tie-breaking or skipping criteria was used to appropriately identify employees for layoff; employees who understand the reason for the layoff and who do not dispute the seniority list generally waive their right to a hearing

Following hearing request

Each employee who requests a hearing, will be served with documentation related to the hearing process

Within 5 calendar days of service of Accusation

Employee submits to the district a written response and Request for Discovery (or the union does it on behalf of everyone served)

Hearings will be scheduled in July

If a hearing is requested, the employee and District personnel appear before an administrative law judge (ALJ) who works for the State of California’s Office of Administrative Hearings. The issues will include whether the employee was properly notified of the layoff, if the district followed the school board’s direction as passed in a Board resolution, and if layoffs occurred in correct order of seniority and credentialing.

By August 10

The administrative law judge will give the district a recommended decision.

By August 15

The school board reviews the ALJ’s recommendations and decides whether to adjust layoffs. Final notices of layoff must be given to the employee no later than August 15. If there is no final layoff notice served, the employee still has a job. Employees served with a final layoff notice remain on a rehire list for 39 months.


 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Fawn Myers, Assistant Superintendent Human Resources
Attachments:
200519 Layoff Timeline for 2020-21
J.5. Board of Education Schedule 2020-21 (8:00 PM)
Rationale:
Two options for proposed Board of Education meeting schedule and agenda prep dates for 2020-21
 
Comments:
Submitted by:
Steve Betando, Superintendent 
Attachments:
200519 DRAFT 2020-21 BOE Schedule and Prep Dates Option 1
200519 DRAFT 2020-21 BOE Schedule and Prep Dates Option 2
J.6. Consideration of consultant contracts in response to the California High Speed Rail Authority's draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR)/Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) (8:10 PM)
Rationale:
The California High Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA) is a State Agency responsible for the planning, design, and construction of the California high speed rail system that will connect the San Francisco Bay Area to Los Angeles. In September 2019, the CHSRA Board of Directors identified the preferred alternative route for the high speed rail system as Alternative 4, which utilizes a blended configuration between San Jose and Gilroy in the existing Caltrain and Union Pacific Railroad corridors before continuing to a dedicated high speed rail alignment through Pacheco Pass.

On April 24th the CHSRA made available the San Jose to Merced draft environmental documents which begins the statutory period for public comment (April 24 – June 8, 2020). An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) are documents that are required to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act and the California Environmental Quality Act. The purpose of these documents is to analyze and disclose a project’s potential effects on the natural and human environment and identify mitigation measures and alternatives to avoid significant effects. An EIS is prepared when there is Federal involvement in the project and an EIR is prepared when the project is subject to State or local jurisdiction. A joint document, an EIR/EIS, may be prepared when both a Federal and State agency are involved. The approval of the final EIR/EIS enables CHSRA to approve the project and proceed to final design and begin construction.

Staff from CHSRA provided a project update at the Board of Education meeting on May 5, 2020. During the meeting Trustees and District staff expressed concerns about the potential impact of Alternative 4 to school district sites and operations. Although the District has no direct influence over the decisions made by CHSRA, the District can ensure that the natural and human environment effects are correctly identified and adequate mitigation measures are identified in the final environmental documents. If the school district can demonstrate unidentified effects or inadequate mitigation measures it could force changes to the project. Also the District can only legally challenge issues, with a few exceptions, raised during the administrative review of a project so the District would likely be legally precluded from challenging the EIR/EIS at a later date by not responding to the draft environmental documents.

In addition to dedicating internal staff resources, the District would need to procure services from two external consultants (legal and environmental) at a total estimated cost of $15,000 to help evaluate, analyze, and respond to the draft EIR/EIS. Given the fiscal implications, staff seeks direction from the Board whether to proceed with entering into contract for consultant services in order to provide formal comment on the EIR/EIS.

 
Financial Impact:
$15,000 from General Fund
Comments:
Submitted by:
Kirsten Perez, Deputy Superintendent and Chief Financial Officer
Steve Betando, Superintendent
J.7. New business: future agenda items / recognitions (8:30 PM)
K. PUPIL DISCIPLINE
L. ADJOURNMENT (8:40 PM)
Rationale:
The next REGULAR meeting of the Board of Education is scheduled for Tuesday, June 2, 2020 with Open Session beginning at 6:00pm.  The agenda will be available on the District's website by 5:00pm Friday, May 29, 2020.
 
Disability Information:
Special Accommodations: In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to access the Board meeting room or to otherwise participate at this meeting, including auxiliary aids or services, please contact Kelly Schriefer at 201-6001. Notification at least 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the District to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to the Board meeting. Documents provided to a majority of the Governing Board regarding an open session item in the agenda will be made available for public inspection in the District Office located at 15600 Concord Circle, Morgan Hill during normal business hours.

Published: May 15, 2020, 4:20 PM

The resubmit was successful.